Or, at least things we SHOULD have learned a long time ago. Like “Don’t jump out of trees!” and “Don’t eat broken glass!” Allow me to add “Don’t ever talk about that brilliant idea you had.” Otherwise, you too may end up charged with pulling a skeptical inquiry group out of your ass.
I mean, let’s think about this…I can’t stand being around people, and I especially cringe when I have to be around people who believe everything they hear (even more so when those people define themselves as “skeptical”). Thus, I am totally the wrong person to gently explain to the woo-afflicted just how and why they are stupider than sawdust. I thought we’d learned that lesson with my conspiracy-theorist friend who is currently on a mission to synthesize a universal religion blending all faiths together and then making them somehow agree with Christianity (using a sledgehammer if necessary). My response was to grab him by both ears and yell “What the fuck is wrong with your brain, man?” Perhaps I am not the natural choice to be a public voice for the sort of kinder, gentler skepticism that is so in vogue these days. Frankly, I’m sick to death of shutting up and trying to not offend people. Some people richly deserve to be offended, if you ask me (not that you did, but go read the disclaimer in the sidebar).
So, not only do I need to figure out how to structure this thing without completely destroying my own mind, but I also need to figure out how to deal with the tone wars. I’m not sure that I am really capable of being the kind of pleasant, neutered, bland skeptical thinker that is favored (and honestly, useful) in these situations. I’m sort of an intellectual street fighter, not a graceful fencer (actually, when I was a fencer, I was constantly steered toward sabre, where small stature and slashing, psychotic aggression are assets instead of liabilities).
And really, I don’t know fuck-all about formal debate. I can smell bullshit, but I couldn’t necessarily tell you where it is. I’m quite sure that I don’t have the academic chops to do it well…with any luck, maybe I can start a ball rolling and hope that someone with a bigger brain and more social smarts takes over so that I can sit back and be the Snarkmaster General. I can hold my own with most people on many things (astronomy, broader science questions, the origins of social constructs and beliefs), but I have major holes in mathematics, biology, and, um, how to deal with people.
People mystify me. I always say that animals (like cats) never do anything that doesn’t make sense. And they don’t, if you’re another cat, or at least understand cat signals. But humans constantly do things that are wacky as shit, or signal one thing and do another, or act in a way that is clearly in contradiction to their stated beliefs. Y’all humans are just completely weird, and I do NOT get you at all. To be quite honest, I’m pretty sick of trying, because every time I figure out what a facial expression means, it suddenly means something else (and spare me the Aspergers’ diagnoses, I’ve heard it all before, thankyouverymuch). A pox on all of you.
However, I’m apparently pretty good at being skeptical. Hey, I’ve been doing it since November 18, 1978, when a ten year old kid saw the images coming from Jonestown and said “I am NEVER going to let anyone do my thinking for me!” There’s something to be said for life experience…if you question things on a regular basis, you tend to make that your default position and do it for everything. Like, say, Dark Energy. Now, I can’t see it, I can’t feel it, can’t really measure it directly, and most emphatically, I don’t “believe in it.” But, observation indicates that something seems to be causing the expansion of the universe to accelerate; “dark energy” is just a phrase used to express the concept of something that we don’t yet understand (because it’s easier than saying “that thing that seems to be causing the expansion of the universe to accelerate”). I can look at the observed situation and think “Yes, indeedy…there’s definitely something there that needs explaining, by all means, let’s go investigate!” but that’s hardly a religious-type belief in the power of dark energy. Do you see the difference, my conspiracy-theory-prone friend? Now, I’d love to “believe” in dark energy. There is just enough old-school Star Wars weenie in me to see the beauty of the name and the brilliance of whoever came up with it. I could totally dig a light-and-dark matter-and-energy kind of universe in a metaphysical way, if I was a completely different person…as it is, all I can do is marvel at the subtle nod to dualism (and probably geekery) and sort of smile every time I hear someone talk about it.
And why the hell don’t those people bitch about gravity? They all whine “Aw, evolution is just a theory!” like that actually proves something. Gravity is just a theory. So is Relativity. They (like evolution) have been extremely well-tested. Your cell phone, when I let go of it, will fall to the pavement and break like the cheap toy it is. It will never fly up and soar away to Mars to live happily with little green men. Unless you’re really into quantum mechanics, in which case you can probably work out an infinitesimal probability for just such an occurrence…but if that’s the case, it’s a good bet that you’re probably here for the dick jokes, not the science. So carry on with that.